Only If is a surreal first-person adventure-puzzle game that takes players on a perplexing journey through the mind of its protagonist, Anthony Clyde. As a seasoned retro gaming enthusiast, it's impossible not to appreciate the game's nostalgic vibe, reminiscent of classic titles from the past. However, amidst the enthusiasm for this retro charm, it's important to address the game's shortcomings.
While the premise of waking up in an unfamiliar bed after a night of partying holds promise, Only If fails to fully deliver on this intriguing concept. The game lacks a cohesive narrative, leaving players with more questions than answers about Anthony's predicament. Although this open-endedness can be seen as an attempt to create a thought-provoking experience, it ultimately leaves players feeling unsatisfied.
Visually, Only If captures the nostalgic essence of retro gaming with its low-polygon graphics and simplistic art style. This intentional design choice taps into the charm of classic games, invoking a sense of familiarity and comfort. However, the lack of visual variety throughout the game's environments can make the experience feel repetitive and uninspired.
In terms of gameplay, Only If presents players with a series of perplexing puzzles that must be solved to progress. This aspect of the game is where its true potential lies, as the puzzles, though challenging, offer an engaging experience for gamers who enjoy using their critical thinking skills. The thrill of unraveling each puzzle piece by piece creates a sense of accomplishment, fostering a desire to push forward despite the game's narrative shortcomings.
Furthermore, Only If features a surreal and atmospheric soundtrack that successfully immerses players in its enigmatic world. The haunting melodies and ambient sounds heighten the game's sense of mystery, further enhancing its retro aesthetic. This attention to auditory detail is commendable and adds to the overall immersive experience.
Ultimately, Only If for PC garners a rating of 2.5/10. While the game evokes nostalgic feelings and offers stimulating puzzles, it falls short in delivering a satisfying narrative and visually diverse experience. Nevertheless, for retro gaming enthusiasts who yearn for a challenging adventure-puzzle game, Only If may provide some enjoyment.
